RoyTalley_18
May 26, 2026
"Just didn’t agree with my baby"
I was hoping this would work out, but my baby got really gassy and fussy after having it. Shipping was fine and everything arrived okay, but when you’re dealing with digestion issues, you just know quickly it’s not the right fit...
sheri-Lawrence
May 13, 2026
"I’m a bit torn because I didn’t expect..."
I’m a bit torn because I didn’t expect instant replies, but the support team took way too long to get back to me. I had to follow up more than once, and even when they finally responded, it felt like I still didn’t really get the help I needed. It just left me feeling like they were there, but not really there.
"Not gonna lie, I’ve ordered a..."
Not gonna lie, I’ve ordered a few times and the products have always shown up fine, but the delivery dates haven’t been super reliable. One of my boxes arrived late, and the tracking barely updated, which was a bit frustrating. It’s not terrible overall, I just wish the shipping was a little more consistent.
hello_amy864
April 28, 2026
"My order did get here on time, which..."
My order did get here on time, which I appreciated, but the shipping box was in rough shape. One side was crushed, and the tape looked like it was barely hanging on by the time it got to my door.
Thankfully nothing was leaking, but some of the cans inside were dented, and it didn’t really feel like it had been packed securely. Since this is baby formula, I think a lot of parents would expect the packaging to be sturdier and handled with a bit more care.
dianesmith7283
April 28, 2026
"Order was mostly right, but the follow-up was lacking"
I ordered a few cans from myorganicformula.com, and the package showed up in good condition. The main formula I needed was correct, so I was relieved about that part.
One of the items wasn’t the size I originally picked, though, which was frustrating. I went back and checked my order confirmation, and it definitely showed something different from what I received.
I did reach out to customer service, and they responded after a little while, but there wasn’t much follow-up after that. It felt like I had to keep things moving myself, which made the whole thing take longer than it should have. Overall, not a terrible experience, but not exactly great either
shannon2005
April 14, 2026
"Refund took way too long"
Dealing with the refund was frustrating. I had to keep following up just to get any updates, and the return instructions weren’t very clear. I expected a much faster response, but the whole thing dragged on way longer than it should have. The reply I finally got didn’t really answer my questions either. I don’t think I’ll be ordering from here again.
JohnSprague
April 09, 2026
"Good formula, but the subscription felt clunkier than others I’ve used"
I do like the formula options, and that part was why I wanted to stick with it. But compared to other subscriptions I’ve had for baby stuff, this one felt more annoying than it should’ve. My refill didn’t process the way I expected, and I ended up digging through emails and checking my account more than once to figure out what was going on. Customer service did get back to me, but it wasn’t exactly quick. Not a horrible experience, just frustrating when you’re counting on formula showing up on time...
michael1978
March 26, 2026
"Clunky experience that felt preventable"
I tried using the site and got frustrated quickly. Pages were slow to load, and I had to click around way too much just to find basic stuff like shipping info and product details, which made the whole experience feel more difficult than it needed to be.
The checkout process wasn’t very clear either, and on my phone a few parts of the page looked messy or poorly laid out. I ended up giving up before placing an order because it felt like a preventable hassle.
hello_bertha454
March 12, 2026
"Everything I need is always gone"
Every time I check, the stuff I actually need is out of stock. I’ll find one thing, then something else is missing, and then I just give up. It’s frustrating because I keep coming back hoping it’ll be available, but nope, same issue again.
rochelle_Campbell79
February 17, 2026
"I’m not sure this was the..."
I’m not sure this was the real deal. The way it was described made it seem authentic, but once I got it, the quality just felt off. Kind of frustrating because the wording felt misleading, and now I’m questioning what I actually bought.
moses.Meyer
January 21, 2026
"Shipping was way slower than I expected"
My order took way longer to show up than I thought it would... like, I knew shipping can be a little unpredictable, but this felt slow. I actually needed it sooner, so it ended up being really frustrating. Maybe if you’re not in any rush it’s fine, but for me, yeah, the shipping just wasn’t great.
hello_ernest897
December 10, 2025
"My Wallet Was Not Ready for This"
I really wanted to like it, but once I saw the price, it felt like my bank account quietly packed its bags and left. For what it offers, I just don’t think it’s worth the money at all. Way too pricey for me.